Log In via Athens
Users' Guides (UG)
Rational Clinical Exam (RCE)
Care at the Close of Life (CCL)
UG Education Guides
RCE Education Guides
CCL Education Guides
Users' Guides to the Medical Literature
1-3 of 3
Chapter e25. How to Use a Noninferiority Trial
Part B Therapy >
Chapter 10.1. Hypothesis Testing
Part B Therapy >
Chapter 11.3. Dealing With Misleading Presentations of Clinical Trial Results
> Eight Guides to Avoid Being Misled >
Beware Misleading Claims of Equivalence
Trials that estimate treatment effects that exclude any patient-important superiority of interventions under evaluation. Equivalence trials require...
Trials that estimate treatment effects that exclude any patient-important superiority of interventions under evaluation. Equivalence trials require
definition of the smallest difference in outcomes between these interventions that patients would consider large enough to justify a preference for the superior intervention (given the intervention's harms and burdens). The confidence interval for the estimated treatment effect at the end of the trial should exclude that difference for the authors to claim equivalence (i.e., the confidence limits should be closer to zero than the minimal patient-important difference). This level of precision often requires investigators to enroll large numbers of patients with large numbers of events. Equivalence trials are helpful when investigators want to see whether a cheaper, safer, simpler (or increasingly often, better method to generate income for the sponsor) intervention is neither better nor worse (in terms of efficacy) than a current intervention. Claims of equivalence are frequent when results are not significant, but one must be alert to whether the confidence intervals exclude differences between the interventions that are as large as or larger than those patients would consider important. If they do not, the trial is indeterminate rather than yielding equivalence.
Not finding what you are looking for?
Do a full-text search for '
Copyright © American Medical Association. All rights reserved. | JAMA | McGraw-Hill Global Education Holdings, LLC.
. Any use is subject to the
Additional Credits and Copyright Information
Your IP address is 188.8.131.52